Alan Smith on loan...

[Numeric]

word is that Smithy is gonna go on loan to Cardiff, as long as he agrees to the move...

not sure what i'm feelin about this, yeah his performance against Southend was poor and he does need first team football, but Cardiff?!!? surely they could have found somewhere better...

whatever happens, i just hope he finds form again and shines as a United player...

[Esox Lucius]

hope not dont want him helping them go up.

he will come good smith like. had it bad recently just needs to get fit and get some confidence in him.

[french_og]

It might do him good to have a couple of months starting up front in a lower league, if he gets a few goals under his belt he will go back to Utd a lot more confident. They are top of the Championship also Cardiff so he will be joining a winning team.

[davemoore]

if he goes he will have to play leeds wonder what sort of reception hell get there

[Will]

I heard Leeds wanted him too, can't see the fans liking that one!

[nick_anarchy]

iv been told leeds were also after him , but dennis wise said he wasnt interested in havin him back at the club .. also its everton hes off on loan too

[Numeric]

Everton?

haven't heard that one...

would much rather him go to Goodison than Cardiff though...

[nick_anarchy]

Everton?

haven't heard that one...

would much rather him go to Goodison than Cardiff though...

init if it is everton then im happy but i dont want him to go anywhere

also we should be making 2 new signings in jan ... can you gues who

[Numeric]

Torres and Hargreaves would be my choice...

[Richierush]

i would'nt mind him coming to everton,especially as our attackin midfielder cahill is injured,where would you play him?up front or midfield,you cant leave johnson out and moyes likes playin the one up ;)

[Numeric]

i don't think there would be much point in playin Smith in mid-field, when Leeds put him in the centre of the park he did a good job but struggled when United asked him to do the same job...

[DJsmallpaul]

I'd have him anyday, match fit or not, & btw Cardiff are shite we battered them all over their pitch & if it wasn't for the homer of a ref we'd have come away with a point or all 3

[nick_anarchy]

Torres and Hargreaves would be my choice...

spot on ... been told my a birdy thrm to are coming .. we have been given 52m for jan so its go out and get them 2 no matter what it costs

[Numeric]

it would be awesome if we could sign both those players, Hargreaves especially...

[nick_anarchy]

it would be awesome if we could sign both those players, Hargreaves especially...

true hes been playin much better the past year , hope he gets back to the way he was before he did his leg ..

ijust hope they sign them 2 !

[Will]

spot on ... been told my a birdy thrm to are coming .. we have been given 52m for jan so its go out and get them 2 no matter what it costs

What if they cost £100m?

[nick_anarchy]

What if they cost £100m?


well that wont happen will it was 22m for torres & 17m for hargreaves but both players want out of their clubs

[Richierush]

lets be honest,yes hargreaves looks alot better now as a player,but do you think if the england fans had'nt have got on his back he would of played like a man on a misssion,i doubt it.he started playin better when he was giving 110% rather than 50% everyone must be able to see it,for england e shud have been givin 110% from the start thats what has pissed me off about him

[nick_anarchy]

lets be honest,yes hargreaves looks alot better now as a player,but do you think if the england fans had'nt have got on his back he would of played like a man on a misssion,i doubt it.he started playin better when he was giving 110% rather than 50% everyone must be able to see it,for england e shud have been givin 110% from the start thats what has pissed me off about him

totaly agree but he was being played wide left & wide right , but playin in the middle for his club ... now he got a right slateing last year and now hes showing to be a promiceing player i hope if he comes to us he does the job needed

[michael00elder]

Alan smith is a great player with plenty of potential, he's still young just needs to get some first team practice, i'm sure most clubs would welcome what he has to offer.....

[Esox Lucius]

would love to have him on loan for us, maybe we could sign him at the end of the season ;)