PUNISHBLUE 001

[Traxx]

People dont have to produce to have a opinion sam.

[The Overfiend]

I understand man, I agree and maybe was a bit rash, but at the same time it's not easy to put effort into writing a track and releasing it, for someone to say it was filler or unimaginitve. Takes a lot of thought to make music man.

[Traxx]

I can understand where you are coming from also. But for each person that thinks a track is a filler there will be another who thinks that its a floor killer. Each to there own, opinions will always vary.

[dirty_bass]

I have to disagree Sam
I can`t really see anything imaginative about Me So Horny. I honestly don`t think it would take long to replicate this tune.
Punish has hit a formula and has been stuck for time now.
The only thing that has changed from the usual heavily compressed loops, is the 2 note synth line, and the sample from Full Metal Jacket.

Humphries track is a bit more imaginative in my opinion, it contains some more interesting production elements (some polyrhythms) and progresses. But then humphries always was the better producer in my opinion.

Overall, how is this a progression (or even something that stands out) from previous punish releases?

[jonnyspeed]

I wish all the people around here who are so negative about this and that would show us what they have done.
It's a weird thing to read someone say this took no imaginitive process and what not, but do you even know how hard it is to learn certain production techniques to even build up to what they are putting out?
In my opinion unless you are a producer or fricking Speedy j or any other producer with a smidge of production technique and skill, can someone really say this is unimaginative or it blows. And that goes for how i feel with many releases, it's one thing to hear a loop a kick and a melody, that's cheap. But there's certain things you cant go wrong with. Maybe I'm just objective, but seriously man. Too much negativity ain't cool.

I think this is a balanced post with a few yes and a few no. What would I do? remove some of the slush off the top end and work at stronger more varied percussion.

As for not having an opinion on what you like just because you aren't a producer is just laughable.

[The Overfiend]

I wish all the people around here who are so negative about this and that would show us what they have done.
It's a weird thing to read someone say this took no imaginitive process and what not, but do you even know how hard it is to learn certain production techniques to even build up to what they are putting out?
In my opinion unless you are a producer or fricking Speedy j or any other producer with a smidge of production technique and skill, can someone really say this is unimaginative or it blows. And that goes for how i feel with many releases, it's one thing to hear a loop a kick and a melody, that's cheap. But there's certain things you cant go wrong with. Maybe I'm just objective, but seriously man. Too much negativity ain't cool.

I think this is a balanced post with a few yes and a few no. What would I do? remove some of the slush off the top end and work at stronger more varied percussion.

As for not having an opinion on what you like just because you aren't a producer is just laughable.

I didn't mean it like that, I mean it in a sense of put yourself in the artist shoes for a second, a track isn't exactly the easiest thing to conjure up.

[The Germ]

pop dat pussy steve pop it!

[dirty_bass]

pop dat pussy steve pop it!

que?

[jonnyspeed]

Agreed - it takes effort and nerve to put a track out

[Heroes]

The 1st thing you have to learn about being a producer is how to take criticism...........

[Traxx]

Shame more people dont think like this.

[Heroes]

I made "me so horny" and own punish so as a labelowner and producer you have to learn to take critisism be it good or bad or from experienced producers or novices. as long as the comments are not hypocritical iam ok with it all !!!!

[Traxx]

:clap:

[The Overfiend]

I made "me so horny" and own punish so as a labelowner and producer you have to learn to take critisism be it good or bad or from experienced producers or novices. as long as the comments are not hypocritical iam ok with it all !!!!

Good Point.

[DEVICE]

as long as theres something for the most of you then mission accomplished :lol:

Everything is not for everbody.

Yea, mission accomplished!!! well done....

[davedogg]

I dig alot of Glenn Wilson's productions.. he's up in my top 5 producers.. but this particular release didn't impress me enough to make me want to buy it..