good or bad is subjective, but the so called "techno legends" base their opinion on the popularity of the tune. I mean virtually every dj big & small, and in the techno and house genres played that tune to death.
Can u honestly blame any1 for naming it song of the year? Dont forget we have heard it 10000x already, so we are jaded lol. but 2 years ago people couldnt get enough of it