well i used to say vinal (bit of a purist) i love my 1210,s and my vinal collection - they are a 90's icon and until 6 months ago i would have beaten any one up who said anything was better than vinal. however i have discovered djing on ableton with wav file from beatport. apart from the fact that the waves seem to have the tops cut off (damn limiters) it has freed me up to do so much more in the way of creative mixing.
so in short vinal is way cooler ableton free's me up to be more creative - i think the croud would prefer the latter x