I think they're ace, Is This It totally changed everything as far as rock/indie is concerned, I think maybe people went a bit too far and put them on a bit of a pedestal, but nontheless they are quality. I dont really like Room On Fire so much, when I listen to it I tend to skip tracks, but I thought First Impressions of Earth was a solid album. It does lose steam a bit towards the end, but its far longer than the other two, so maybe they should have stuck with the 45 minute sort of mark. I absolutely love Heart In A Cage and The Other Side.