I understand all that (always have done) - i just don't think that mix is all that.
i've heard of plenty of off the hook sets with heaps of energy without resorting high bpms. sets with bag loads of energy, progression and quality tracks and better beatmatched. Granted beatmatching isn't everything, but this particular set just doesn't tick enough boxes to make up for it short comings.
I'm by no means calling Jeff a crap DJ. He clearly isn't. I just think this mix is massively over-rated.