The path he's chose will never work - when he started playing places like Godskitchen and Gatecrasher, it affected his productions because he has become removed from the underground and is only encouraged to go lighter all the time. Look at how his productions have gradually got lighter and lighter over the past year, from the sheer brilliance of ding-a-ling to the airy fairy City to City.
I gave up on him when he was last on Warmduscher's show and played an all trance set. If you read the comments people make about him on the GK and GC boards, you can see that they just don't really appreciate hard trance. They like it at first as a novelty, then after a few weeks rip it to death. Scot is not a good enough technical dj to be appreciated as a trance dj, so eventually that crowd are going to reject him.