how to improve this section...

[rhythmtech]

if its crap then why are these people not posting anymore?

i know you've blasted quite a few fatcollective tracks b4 yet these tracks go on to get released on big labels.. weird how that works eh?

good music is just goos music.. the public buy the records no matter what you or i say about them on hereand the public have bought many of the fatcollectives records..

if, like you claim, content is subjective, then how is comparing a certain style to another producers "all about production"?

you only need to look over your older posts to see this happening.

[dirty_bass]

if its crap then why are these people not posting anymore?

i know you've blasted quite a few fatcollective tracks b4 yet these tracks go on to get released on big labels.. weird how that works eh?

good music is just goos music.. the public buy the records no matter what you or i say about them on hereand the public have bought many of the fatcollectives records..

if, like you claim, content is subjective, then how is comparing a certain style to another producers "all about production"?

you only need to look over your older posts to see this happening.

ah I see where this was going. thought so
Well, it was only the fat collective, and this was probably about a year and a half ago when they were posting up about a new track a day, which all sounded the same to me.
I still think what they were doing then was very much mimicking the LondonTechno Mafia, they were wearing their influences on their sleeves. Still do to a certain degree in some productions, although some of them have developed their own take on the sound now, and all power to them.
And I never commented whether it would sell or not, sales don`t mean a hell of a lot to me.
I don`t hold sales to be anything to do with good music.
Otherwise hideous manufactured bands like Girls Aloud wouldn`t sell so many records.

However, apart from that, I never really got on the content tip too much.
If I do it`s generally for a very strong reason.

anyway this all goes onto the point about fragile egos.
If you put your tracks up in a place where people can comment on them, expect people to comment on them, and don`t always expect to be happy with the comments.
Otherwise put your tracks up on myspace and remove the comments option.



Now

why do we need a mod in here?

[dan the acid man]

not had time to read all of this yet apart from the first couple of posts, will do tomorrow.

Im not a fan of the rating system though, as Scott says it would probably result in fewer posts in here, as people will feel they've contributed by just pressing a button saying they like it, or they don't.

Yes it's been quiet in here for a while, but so has every other section of the forum really.

When i first joined i was in here everyday listening to tunes and giving feedback, but lack of time and some people getting upset over criticism means i had quite a long break from visiting this section (even though i am a mod in here:ohdear: )

i am slowly starting to visit here more though, especially as we now have some new posters posting tracks

[MARK ANXIOUS]

wow, it's all went off there then. calm down ya fukas!!!



well i don't post in here alot, purely because of time. but it doesnt means i don't care what happens here. from what i read in here yesterday, everyone's feedback on ppl tracks has been brilliant, really constructive and really useful. i think this place is no different to each time i've bobbed on over the years, a great range of music. i just wanna give it more purpose. i think you're right, if i come on here every month and take the best 1 or 2 tracks for the BOA Radio thing, then there ya go, we have a reason and a goal for ppl to aim for.

i'm try to aim for an ftp upload thing and i'll get more involved. as for a mod, well in my experience here, the more mods getting actively involved, the better. i think it's a good idea baz, i will give it more thought over the weekend and let's talk next week!!!

:)

[rhythmtech]

wow, it's all went off there then. calm down ya fukas!!!



well i don't post in here alot, purely because of time. but it doesnt means i don't care what happens here. from what i read in here yesterday, everyone's feedback on ppl tracks has been brilliant, really constructive and really useful. i think this place is no different to each time i've bobbed on over the years, a great range of music. i just wanna give it more purpose. i think you're right, if i come on here every month and take the best 1 or 2 tracks for the BOA Radio thing, then there ya go, we have a reason and a goal for ppl to aim for.

i'm try to aim for an ftp upload thing and i'll get more involved. as for a mod, well in my experience here, the more mods getting actively involved, the better. i think it's a good idea baz, i will give it more thought over the weekend and let's talk next week!!!

:)

sounds good mark..

just to re-itterate. im not pushing for it myself but i am willing to do it if you want.. my "job" lets me be on here all day anyway.

but whats more important is to get someone, no matter who it is, thats willing and able to put the time in.